How to choose an AI video agency: 12 questions to ask before you sign
Anyone with a subscription can make AI video now. These 12 questions show, in one call, who will give you an ad that sells and who will give you a file full of problems.
Photo: Vitaly Gariev, Unsplash, Unsplash LicenseA good AI video agency shows ads for real brands, gives you a script and key frames to approve before it generates any video, puts deadlines, revisions and rights in the contract, and knows how AI content has to be labelled since 2 August 2026. These 12 questions check all of that in one call.
- Look at ads for real brands in your category. Tool demo reels tell you nothing about the agency.
- Approve a script and key frames before any video exists. That keeps revisions cheap.
- In the contract: deadline, number of revisions, deliverables and who owns the video.
- The agency needs a plan for AI labelling under Article 50 of the AI Act and the Meta and TikTok rules.
- Red flags: "unlimited revisions", celebrity faces without consent, free accounts for music and voice.
How do you check the portfolio and the team?
1. Show me 3 ads for real brands, ideally in my category.
AI model demo reels look impressive because they are made without constraints. An ad has constraints: a specific product, a label, brand colours, 15 seconds. So ask for ads that real brands have run. While you watch, check three things: does the character's face stay the same between shots, does the product look identical in every scene, can you read the text on the pack.
2. Who writes the script and who directs?
Generation is the last step. Before it, someone decides what happens in the first 2 seconds, who the character is and what makes a person stop scrolling. Ask who that person is and which ads they have run. If the answer is "the tool does it", the idea will be the tool's.
What should you ask about process, revisions and deadlines?
3. Will I approve a script and key frames before you generate video?
A key frame is a still image that shows what each scene will look like: character, light, product. Approve the frames and the video rarely surprises you. Skip them and your first feedback lands on a finished video, so every change starts from zero.
4. How many revision rounds are included, and what counts as a revision?
The norm is 2 rounds per video. Get the definition in writing: a revision is a change within the approved script, and a new idea is a new order. More on where that line sits in how an AI video ad is made.
5. What is the deadline, and what happens if you miss it?
The deadline should be a date in the contract, and being late should cost the agency something. Ask when the clock stops too, for example while they wait for your feedback. That is fair, as long as it is written down. At mAInds, for example, the first videos arrive within 7 working days of approved scripts, and if we are late through our own fault, the videos delivered after the deadline are free.
6. What exactly do I receive?
Ask for a list. A good one reads like this: 9:16, 4:5 and 16:9, several hooks per idea, files with and without captions, subtitles, separate audio, and a broadcast master for TV. If the quote just says "video", you will get one file.
Who owns the video, and what about rights?
7. Who owns the video after I pay?
Ask for a written transfer of rights to the final video, the script and the source files after payment. Copyright in purely generated content is limited, so protection comes from the human work in the script, direction and edit, and from what the contract says. We list exactly what belongs in it in rights to AI video.
8. Which licences cover the music, voice and tools?
Most AI tools for video, voice and music grant commercial use only on paid plans. Ask which plan the agency uses for each. If the answer is "a free account", your ad may have no right to run.
9. Will you use real people's faces?
A generated stranger is a normal technique, as long as it is labelled. The face of a real person, whether an actor, a founder or a celebrity, needs written consent for that specific use. An agency that says "we can do anyone" is passing the risk to you.
How does the agency follow AI rules and protect your product?
10. How do you label AI content?
Since 2 August 2026, Article 50 of the AI Act requires deepfake content, meaning realistic generated people, places or events, to be disclosed clearly at the latest at first exposure. The duty sits with the deployer, the party using the AI system, so settle in the contract who discloses what and how. The platforms add their own rules: TikTok requires an AI-generated content disclaimer for videos that are generated or significantly modified by AI, and Meta applies an "AI info" label to ads significantly edited with its own AI tools. A good agency hands over the video with a ready plan for what gets labelled and how. Details in AI ads: the rules from August 2026.
11. How will you keep my product and brand accurate?
The right answer sounds like a process: product photos from several angles, a character sheet, the brand palette, and a frame-by-frame check of the label, the logo and the shape. "Just send us the logo" means the product will look roughly like yours.
How will you know whether the video works?
12. What will we measure, and where will I see it?
Agree on the metrics with the agency before launch and ask for direct access to the ad report itself. If the offer promises views, ask how a view is counted: in TikTok Ads Manager "Video views" counts every time the video starts to play, replays excluded, so also look at how many people reach the second second.
How guaranteed views work, and how to check they are real, is covered in guaranteed views.
Studio, agency or freelancer: who is right for what?
Very different suppliers sell "AI video". Before the 12 questions, decide which type you need.
| Supplier | Strength | Weakness | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| VFX and 3D studio | complex 3D shots, cinema quality, TV experience | longer timeline, higher price | brand films, TV campaigns |
| Marketing agency with AI video | ads built to sell, many versions for testing | less complex 3D work | Meta and TikTok ads, seasonal campaigns |
| Freelancer | low price, quick start | capacity, contract, cover when ill | a single video with a clear brief |
| DIY with an AI tool | cheapest on paper | hours of generations, editing, sound, rights | internal tests and ideas |
Many brands use two suppliers: a studio for the big film once a year and an agency for the monthly ads. Whichever you choose, ask the same 12 questions. The answers on deadlines, rights and revisions usually settle it.
What are the red flags with an AI video agency?
- A portfolio made only of tool demos or other studios' work.
- A price "per video" with no number of scenes, seconds or versions. How to compare such quotes is in how much an AI video ad costs.
- No stage for script and key frames.
- "Unlimited revisions", or nothing written about revisions.
- The same avatar in ads for different clients.
- Silence on rights and licences.
- A promise of a celebrity face with no contract with that person.
- Nobody brings up AI labelling.
- Views or results you only ever see in screenshots.
Checklist for the agency call
Print it or keep it on a second screen. For each question, mark whether you hear the good answer or the red flag.
| Question | Good answer | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Ads for real brands? | 3 ads in your category, with a real product | only tool demo reels |
| 2. Who writes and who directs? | named people who run ads | "the AI does it" |
| 3. Script and key frames before video? | yes, with an approval deadline | you see the video only at the end |
| 4. How many revision rounds? | 2 rounds per video, in the contract | "unlimited" or nothing written |
| 5. Deadline, and what if it slips? | a date and a penalty on the agency | "depends on the model" |
| 6. What do I receive? | a list: formats, versions, clean files | one 16:9 file |
| 7. Who owns the video? | written transfer after payment | silence or "it stays ours" |
| 8. Music, voice and tool licences? | paid plans with a commercial licence | free accounts |
| 9. Real people's faces? | only with written consent | "we can do anyone" |
| 10. AI labelling? | a clear plan for Article 50 and the platforms | "nobody checks" |
| 11. Product accuracy? | references and a shot-by-shot check | "just send a logo" |
| 12. How do we measure results? | metrics, report access, a definition of a view | a phone screenshot |
If you want to hold us to the same list, the mAInds guarantees are written in the terms and our work is in the portfolio. Before talking to any agency, prepare an AI video brief: it makes the answers specific.
Questions
Two or three. Send all of them the same brief and ask the same 12 questions, or you end up comparing different things. More than three calls rarely adds new information and delays the start. If two agencies answer equally well, decide on the portfolio in your category and on who shows you key frames faster.
You can ask for ideas and sample key frames based on your brief. A full free video is rare, because generation and editing take hours. A fair compromise is a small paid first order of one to three videos. That way you check the process, the deadlines and the quality before a bigger commitment.
Agree on it in the contract. The minimum is the final videos in every format, versions without captions and separate audio. Source files, key frames and character sheets matter if someone else will continue the work. If the agency refuses to hand them over even for a fee, you stay dependent on it.
First check the contract: what the penalty is and when the clock stops, for example while the agency waits for your reply. Ask for a new date in writing and what you get for the delay. If the contract says nothing about delays, start from question 5 next time.
Ask us the 12 questions
See the offers and book a 30-minute call. We will answer every question and show you ads close to your category.
See the offers
Magnet Minds